Manufacturers How we rate

The number

How we rate

A sum of three sourced lines, out of 100. It is not a product review, and it does not sort the list.

Our mission is to investigate, verify and feature companies who hold themselves to an American made standard.

The three lines that count

Each line is full, half, none, or unknown. Full takes the whole weight. Half takes half. None is zero. Unknown is left out of the total, so a missing fact does not look like a failing grade.

Weights
Line Full Half None Unknown
Who owns and runs it 40 20 0 Left out
Where it is made 40 20 0 Left out
Inputs from America 20 10 0 Left out

What each line means

40 points

Who owns and runs it

Full when the record is American-owned and American-run, and the confidence is “reported.” Half when that same code is only partly sourced. None when a foreign parent or foreign control is established. Unknown when the ownership code is unverified, or the confidence is unverified.

40 points

Where it is made

Full when the goods this record covers are made in the United States, reported. Half when that account is only partial, or when production is split across countries. None when the manufacturing is abroad. Unknown when the plant is unverified. A past chapter that the record says has ended stays in the change log. It does not by itself cut a current “made here” line in half.

20 points

Inputs from America

Full when every component comes from the United States and the confidence is “reported.” Half when the origins are mixed: some from the United States and some foreign, any component marked mixed, or a known origin beside an unknown one. Half also when every component comes from the United States and the confidence is only partial. None when every component is foreign. Unknown, and left out of the total, when inputs are left off the file, the code is unknown, the confidence is unverified, or every component origin is unknown.

A scored inputs line is a component list. Each row names the part, its share, and its origin, and the shares total 100. The profile prints that list under Inputs from America, with the short note and its sources. When the sources do not give those shares, leave the field off or set the code to unknown. Do not invent a percentage.

Automation is on the card and worth zero

The fourth line is automation. If the sources support a heavily automated shop, and the company is already American-owned and American-run, the breakdown says so. That line is worth 0. It does not add points. It does not take points off. The company stays in alphabetical order.

If automation is not established, the line says “Not established” and the figure stays “Not in the score.” An empty field is not a penalty, and it is not a claim that the shop is all hand work.

What the number is not

It does not sort the home list or a category shelf. It does not measure whether the fork feels good in your hand. It does not stand in for a cap table, a mill certificate, or a floor audit. When a line is thin, the points follow the record that is actually there.

How a record is written

How a record is written

A file on each manufacturer. Two facts, kept apart.

The two lines

01

Who owns and runs it

Who owns the company, and who runs it day to day. A plant in the United States with a foreign parent stays on the foreign-parent side of this line. The factory address does not change the owner.

02

Where it is made

Where the manufacturing happens. A company owned in the United States and producing abroad is recorded as not made in the USA, or as split when the work really is in more than one place.

What gets filed

Each company is a JSON file in this site’s repository. The page is that file. Profiles are not kept in Netlify Blobs.

A review or a proposed edit can be sent from a manufacturer page, or from the corrections page. Request a review asks for a company that already exists to be reviewed. Suggest a company names a manufacturer that is not on the list. Each note waits in a queue. Nothing is written into a file from the form, and nothing appears on the site until a person has checked it. An edit that holds up is applied later, in the repository. A suggestion does not add the company by itself.

The page stays on the manufacturer: owners, plant, dated changes, sources. A few photographs of goods can be filed when the company published them. Patterns, prices, and the cart stay on the company’s own site.

A made-in-USA directory can put a name on a lead list. It does not fill this one, and this site does not copy that directory’s filters or product grids.

If a document is missing, or two accounts disagree, the profile says so. A fact that was not read is not written up as established.

When a shop is heavily automated

Some companies are American-founded, American-owned, and American-run, and the plant is also heavily automated. When the sources support that, the file can include a short note: a label, a sentence or two, and the source ids.

The note is a fact about the shop. It is not a warning. It does not move the company down the list or off it. The list on the front page is alphabetical.

If the sources do not establish how automated the plant is, leave the field off. An empty field means not established. It does not mean someone verified a fully manual shop, and the file should not store heavilyAutomated: false.

Set the note only when the ownership line is already American-owned and American-run, and the write-up supports an American founding. A foreign-owned plant does not get this note. Using some machines is not enough. The sources have to support calling the shop heavily automated.

Shelves, then the file

Categories are how a shopper browses: flatware now, and another shelf when a company is filed under it. The category page names the goods and the manufacturer. The profile is still the company, with the change log and the sources.

Three lines are scored, in the table above. Automation is the fourth line, shown, and worth zero.